January 19, 1964 – Balboa Stadium
Eastern Division Squad – White Jersey, Blue Trim
| 15 | Jack Kemp* | Buffalo | Quarterback |
| 16 | Babe Parilli | Boston | Quarterback |
| 20 | Gino Cappelletti | Boston | End |
| 24 | Ron Hall | Boston | Defensive Back |
| 27 | Freddy Glick | Houston | Defensive Back |
| 31 | Bill Mathis | New York | Fullback |
| 33 | Cookie Gilchrist | Buffalo | Fullback |
| 40 | Tony Banfield | Houston | Defensive Back |
| 43 | Jim Norton | Houston | Defensive Back |
| 45 | Larry Garron | Boston | Fullback |
| 47 | Willie West | Buffalo | Defensive Back |
| 51 | Nick Buoniconti | Boston | Linebacker |
| 52 | Bob Schmidt | Boston | Center |
| 53 | Tom Addison | Boston | Linebacker |
| 55 | Larry Grantham | New York | Linebacker |
| 58 | Mike Stratton | Buffalo | Linebacker |
| 63 | Bob Talamini | Houston | Guard |
| 66 | Billy Shaw | Buffalo | Guard |
| 70 | Tom Sestak | Buffalo | Defensive Tackle |
| 72 | Larry Eisenhauer | Boston | Defensive End |
| 73 | Billy Neighbors | Boston | Guard |
| 74 | Charles Long | Boston | Guard |
| 76 | Rich Michael | Houston | Tackle |
| 77 | Stew Barber | Buffalo | Tackle |
| 78 | Ed Husmann | Houston | Defensive Tackle |
| 82 | Bob Dee | Boston | Defensive End |
| 83 | Ernie Warlick | Buffalo | End |
| 85 | Bake Turner | New York | End |
| 87 | Charlie Hennigan | Houston | End |
* Jack Kemp was suffering from the flu, and was askled by his doctor not to participate in the game.
Western Division Squad – Red Jersey, White Trim
| 00 | Jim Otto | Oakland | Center |
| 16 | Cotton Davidson | Oakland | Quarterback |
| 18 | Tobin Rote | San Diego | Quarterback |
| 19 | Lance Alworth | San Diego | End |
| 22 | Keith Lincoln | San Diego | Fullback |
| 23 | Paul Lowe | San Diego | Halfback |
| 24 | Fred Williamson | Oakland | Defensive Back |
| 26 | Goose Gonsoulin | Denver | Defensive Back |
| 28 | Johnny Robinson | Kansas City | Defensive Back |
| 32 | Clem Daniels | Oakland | Fullback |
| 45 | Dave Grayson | Kansas City | Defensive Back |
| 48 | Duane Wood | Kansas City | Defensive Back |
| 50 | Chuck Allen | San Diego | Linebacker |
| 55 | Jim Fraser | Denver | Linebacker |
| 56 | Emil Karas | San Diego | Linebacker |
| 63 | Arch Matsos | Oakland | Linebacker |
| 64 | Bud McFadin | Denver | Defensive Tackle |
| 65 | Wayne Hawkins | Oakland | Guard |
| 66 | Walt Corey | Kansas City | Linebacker |
| 71 | Ed Budde | Kansas City | Guard |
| 72 | Dave Costa | Oakland | Defensive Tackle |
| 73 | Jim Tyrer | Kansas City | Tackle |
| 74 | Ron Mix | San Diego | Tackle |
| 75 | Ernie Wright | San Diego | Tackle |
| 77 | Ernie Ladd | San Diego | Defensive Tackle |
| 80 | Fred Arbanas* | Kansas City | End |
| 84 | Art Powell | Oakland | End |
| 86 | Earl Faison | San Diego | Defensive End |
| 87 | Mel Branch | Kansas City | Defensive End |
*Fred Arbanas suffered a knee injury in all-star practice, and was replaced in the game by San Diego’s Dave Kocourek.
